Welcome to Reilly's Plates & Pours
Reilly's Plates & Pours, nestled in the heart of New York City at 38 W 48th St, is a must-visit culinary gem. With an inviting atmosphere and friendly staff, diners rave about the exceptional service, particularly from standout team members like Jules. The menu boasts delightful offerings including succulent salmon, hearty shepherd's pie, and popular mozzarella sticks. Seasonal cocktails sparkle, complementing tasty small plates that are perfect for sharing. Whether you’re stopping by before a Broadway show or enjoying a festive night out, Reilly’s promises an unforgettable experience filled with flavorful dishes and a vibrant ambiance.
Reilly's Plates & Pours: Reviews & Ratings
Wow! Went solely here based on reviews and was not disappointed! The staff is as friendly as they say. Our server, Jules, was so sweet & really was incredible also very attentive. The food was amazing. I got the salmon and it was great. Shepherds pie is a must. And mozzarella sticks, obviously wonderful. Great cocktails especially to the seasonal holiday specials. Perfect atmosphere — a must go if you’re visiting the city!!
I enjoyed a quick dinner before a Broadway show. The house pilsner is a refreshing thirst quencher. The tasty chicken and watermelon salad included 4 strips of grilled chicken, multiple 2-inch chunks of watermelon, blue cheese crumbles and lots of fresh baby spinach. Despite it being Happy Hour, my table for one got rapid helpful service.
Stopped in for a beer and shared 3 small plates absolutely delicious, staff were friendly and not intrusive. Small plates feed 2 of us with left overs, good sized portions.
Jules at the bar was amazing! Great service! Great attitude! Great food! No complaints! We showed up for our anniversary and were welcomed with music bingo! Loved it! Good music, not to mention, we won! Jules is great and will definitely be back to visit when in town :)
Service was a little slow but overall we had a good time. We ordered the garbage sink appetizer which did not disappoint and the fact it’s served in a sink was awesome.
Loved my time here! Naomi at the bar was wonderful and attentive. Really great beers to try. Loved the Juice Sloop IPA and the Hazy Jane. Would definitely come back. I love that this is in the city but still has a small town local pub vibe. If you don’t eat anything else definitely try the truffle fries. They’ll keep you somewhat sober and satisfied! The dipping sauce is excellent.
Hidden Gem! We are a traveling family so we are very accustomed to eating out all over the world. They have kids menus and crayons! My kids loved the mini burgers and chicken fingers. Our food was excellent, and so were the drinks. Great prices and a great location. Skip the trendy expensive and tourist traps. You won't be disappointed.
Reilly's Irish Pub is an absolute gem in New York! The atmosphere is lively, the drinks are top-notch, and the service is always friendly. Special shoutout to Naomi – hands down the best bartender in the city! She's incredibly attentive, makes amazing cocktails, and brings such great energy to the place. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area!
Location
-
38 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036, United States Hotline: +1 212-764-7980
Welcome to Reilly's Plates & Pours, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of New York City at 38 W 48th St. This vibrant establishment offers a harmonious blend of mouthwatering dishes and a lively atmosphere that resonates with both locals and visitors alike.
Upon stepping inside, you're welcomed by an ambiance that complements its menu—dynamic, inviting, and a touch sophisticated. The friendly staff, often highlighted in glowing reviews, embody the spirit of hospitality that Reilly's is known for. A standout, server Jules, has received acclaim for her attentive service and warm demeanor, making every guest feel celebrated from the moment they arrive.
The food at Reilly's is where the true magic happens. Diners rave about the scrumptious salmon and the legendary shepherd's pie, a must-try that captures the essence of comfort food and culinary creativity. For those looking to indulge in sharable delights, the selection of small plates is perfect. One customer's experience involved sharing three delectable small plates that proved to be generous in portion and rich in flavor, ideal for a casual night out or an intimate gathering with friends.
Of course, no visit is complete without trying their craft cocktails, particularly the seasonal holiday specials that have been described as both refreshing and festive. Cocktail enthusiasts will appreciate the variety and the attention to detail found in each drink preparation. The house pilsner is called a thirst quencher, perfectly suited for pairing with the robust flavors of the dishes on offer.
The atmosphere at Reilly's Plates & Pours is both lively and relaxed—ideal for a pre-Broadway show dinner or winding down after a long day of exploration. The unique touches in presentation, like the famed garbage sink appetizer, create a memorable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more. Whether you’re indulging in a hearty meal or sipping on one of their uniquely crafted cocktails, Reilly's offers something for every palate.
In a city filled with dining options, Reilly's Plates & Pours stands out not just for its flavorful fare, but for the warmth of its service and the joy it brings to those who walk through its doors. It's a place where good food meets good company, making it an essential stop for anyone visiting the city.